“I’m concerned about dry skin.”
“I’ve started paying attention to my health checkup results.”
“I want to review my diet for menopause.”
From your late 30s to your 50s, don’t you ever wonder about “oils that seem good for the body” because of these feelings?
Flaxseed oil, olive oil, and coconut oil.
They are all common, but they do not all work the same way.
In this article, we will organize what can be expected and what cannot yet be stated definitively, focusing on studies involving humans.
The first thing I want to convey is the idea of reviewing some of the oil you currently use rather than increasing your oil intake.
*This article contains affiliate advertisements.
This is general nutritional information and is not intended for diagnosis or treatment.
It does not mean that the beauty or health benefits of the featured products themselves have been proven by the cited papers.
For oil, “quantity” and “what you replace it with” are important
When choosing oil for health, it is important not only “what you consume” but also “what you use it in place of.”
The WHO recommends replacing saturated fatty acids with unsaturated fatty acids and the like.
Saturated fatty acids are also found in butter and coconut oil.
WHO guidelines on fats
However, even oils that seem good for your health should not be added to your usual diet without limit.
Rather than thinking, “I must drink oil every morning,” start by reviewing some of the oil or dressing you use in your cooking.
Choose a method you can continue.
1. Olive Oil | An option for balancing your overall diet
What we want to focus on regarding olive oil is research on cardiovascular health.
The PREDIMED study, republished in 2018, compared dietary interventions in 7,447 middle-aged and older men and women at high risk for cardiovascular disease.
The group on a Mediterranean diet that incorporated extra virgin olive oil had fewer occurrences of the combined evaluation items of myocardial infarction, stroke, and cardiovascular death than the control group.
Estruch et al., 2018, original paper
It is not an effect of “olive oil alone”
This study examines dietary habits that include vegetables, beans, fish, and more.
Therefore, it cannot be said that “drinking olive oil can prevent disease.”
Also, the subjects were middle-aged and older people with high cardiovascular risk, and the same results may not apply to healthy women in their late 30s.
The original study had issues with the allocation procedure, and it was re-analyzed in the 2018 version.
It is necessary to read it with this point in mind.
In daily life, you might consider incorporating it as part of the oil used in salad dressings or cooking.
It is not a miracle cure for beauty or menopause, but an option for balancing your diet.
2. Flaxseed oil | There is a small-scale study regarding skin
Flaxseed oil contains alpha-linolenic acid, a type of omega-3 fatty acid.
In terms of beauty, there is a study published in 2011 that targeted women with sensitive skin.
The study divided women into two groups of 13 each, testing the intake of flaxseed oil or safflower oil for 12 weeks.
In the flaxseed oil group, improvements were reported in indicators such as skin moisture content and transepidermal water loss.
Neukam et al., 2011, paper abstract
It cannot be said that ‘drinking it will cure dry skin’
Because it is a study with few subjects, the results cannot be generalized to all women.
It is not a study that proved the improvement of spots, wrinkles, or sagging, nor does it guarantee that commercially available flaxseed oil products will have the same results.
It is appropriate to view it as ‘there are studies showing a relationship with skin condition, but it is still limited.’
Please do not use it as a substitute for moisturizing care or necessary medical treatment.
Follow product labeling for usage
Flaxseed oil for raw consumption is suitable for use on salads and the like, not for stir-frying.
Nisshin Oillio also advises that their flaxseed oil is not suitable for heat cooking.
Manufacturer’s usage precautions
Since storage methods vary by product, do not assume that ‘all flaxseed oil should be refrigerated,’ and check the label.
3. Coconut oil | Be cautious about prioritizing it for health purposes
Coconut oil has an image of being good for beauty and diet.
However, a 2020 meta-analysis summarizing 16 reports showed that compared to non-tropical vegetable oils such as olive oil, LDL cholesterol was on average about 10.5 mg/dL higher.
No significant improvement was confirmed in indicators related to body fat either. Neelakantan et al., 2020, paper
This does not mean that everyone’s levels will rise in the same way.
However, it is a result that makes it difficult to use as a reason to actively switch from other vegetable oils for health purposes.
Do not confuse it with MCT oil research
Coconut oil and MCT oil, which has adjusted components, are not the same thing.
It is inappropriate to introduce the research results of MCT oil as the effects of regular coconut oil as is.
American Heart Association commentary
If you like the scent of coconut and use it in cooking or sweets, there is no need to deny that way of enjoying it.
However, I do not recommend adding them to your daily diet for the purpose of “burning fat” or “balancing female hormones.”
Do not try to solve menopausal discomfort with oil alone
There is also research regarding flaxseed and menopause.
However, it is necessary to distinguish between flaxseed seeds, powder, and extracted components, and flaxseed oil.
In a 2012 comparative study, there was no significant difference between flaxseed-containing foods and a placebo in improving hot flashes.
Pruthi et al., 2012, original research paper
Research results vary, and it cannot be definitively stated that “flaxseed oil improves menopausal symptoms.”
Research summary by the US NCCIH
If you are having trouble with daily life due to hot flashes or sleep problems, please consult a gynecologist or other professional before buying more oil.
You can balance eating a healthy diet with receiving necessary medical care.
Product candidates to consider for around 2,000 to 3,000 yen
From here on, these are purchase candidates for incorporating the types of oils used in research into your daily life. These are not the same products used in the research, and there is no guarantee of effectiveness.
Prices are based on official listed prices at the time of the survey and will vary depending on shipping costs, retailers, and timing.
Candidate for cooking: Melgarejo Selection 500ml EXV Olive Oil
Official listed price: 2,700 yen (tax included)
This is a candidate for extra virgin olive oil. For those who want to replace some of the oil they use in cooking.
Since it is 500ml, it is more rational for those who only use a small amount to choose a smaller capacity product, even if it is below the budget. It does not mean that more expensive oil has stronger health benefits.
For those who want to use individual packaging: NIPPN Flaxseed Oil Effect 4.4g x 31 bags
Regular price: 2,160 yen (tax included)
Individually packaged in 4.4g bags. A candidate for those who want to reduce the hassle of measuring.
Although it is a Food with Function Claims, the notification is regarding LDL cholesterol and blood pressure, and it is not a label that recognizes effectiveness for skin or menopausal symptoms.
It is not a product that the government has individually reviewed and approved for effectiveness, and it cannot be used for treatment purposes.
Explanation of notification label
Instead of a subscription, you can also consider checking the conditions for a regular one-time purchase first.
Candidate for enjoying the aroma: BROWN SUGAR 1ST. Organic Extra Virgin Coconut Oil 425g
Official listed price: 2,030 yen (tax included)
This is a candidate for those who want to use coconut flavor in cooking or sweets.
In this article, we do not recommend this product for beauty, diet, or menopause countermeasures.
It is not a product that people looking to review their oil intake for health purposes need to choose first.
Summary | Rather than “adding good oils,” choose oils that suit your diet
Organizing based on this research,
-
Olive oil: Can be considered as part of a healthy dietary pattern.
-
Flaxseed oil: There are small-scale studies on skin, but beauty benefits are still limited.
-
Coconut oil: You can enjoy the flavor, but be cautious about the evidence for prioritizing it for health purposes.
None of these oils are things that every woman must buy.
If you are taking medication, especially anticoagulants or antiplatelet drugs, or if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, please consult your doctor or pharmacist before taking flaxseed oil continuously for health purposes.
NCCIH safety information
It is okay not to keep adding things for the sake of beauty and health.
First, look at your usual diet and review some of the oils you use.
Why not start with such a small choice?
