How to Choose Extra Virgin Olive Oil You Will Love Using

Tasting and using ENZO’s Bold, Medium and Delicate oils made one thing clear to me: bottles carrying the same extra virgin designation can taste noticeably different. That variety is part of what makes olive oil interesting to cook with.

Choosing a bottle becomes easier when you know what those differences mean. Start with freshness and how the oil was produced, then consider the flavors you enjoy and the dishes you make most often.

Vincent Ricchiuti, ENZO Olive Oil’s co-founder and chief operating officer, has spent much of his life around that process. A fourth-generation farmer, he grew up working alongside his father and grandfather in the family’s agricultural business. He now leads day-to-day business and production operations across the P-R Farms portfolio, including ENZO Olive Oil and ENZO’S TABLE.

The family grows its olives and mills its oil in California’s Central San Joaquin Valley. In a written interview, Ricchiuti explained how that experience translates into practical advice for anyone choosing a bottle.

Start with what extra virgin means

Extra virgin is a grade of olive oil with chemical and sensory requirements. Ricchiuti points to limits on free acidity and the absence of sensory defects as part of that designation.

“The designation is an important starting point, but knowing where an oil comes from and how it’s handled gives you a more complete picture of its quality,” he says.

The California Olive Oil Council’s certification program shows how those standards are assessed. Its seal requires chemical analysis and a sensory evaluation of a representative sample from a lot. Laboratory testing measures chemical characteristics, while a trained tasting panel evaluates the oil’s sensory qualities.

For a shopper, a verifiable quality seal offers useful information about the oil. Organic certification concerns how it was produced. Understanding what each certification covers helps you read the bottle with more confidence.

Then look for details about the oil itself: when the olives were harvested, where they were grown and who made it.

Check the harvest date and the packaging

Ricchiuti considers the harvest date one of the most helpful details on a bottle. It identifies when the olives were picked, giving you a clearer sense of the oil’s age.

UC Davis’s olive oil buying guide also recommends checking the harvest date and choosing packaging that protects the oil from light. Dark glass and tins are practical options.

Origin adds another piece of information. Look for where the olives were grown and where the oil was produced. At ENZO, Ricchiuti says the estate model lets the family oversee growing, harvesting, milling and bottling, with olives processed within hours of picking.

That short interval helps preserve quality. UC Davis’s production guidance recommends minimizing the time between harvest and processing.

“For us, estate-grown is about both quality and control,” Ricchiuti says.

For the buyer, that model also provides traceability: you can identify whose olives went into the oil and who handled the production.

Let the olive variety guide your choice

ENZO’s three oils offer an introduction to different olive varieties. Delicate is made from Arbequina olives, Medium from Arbosana and Bold from Koroneiki.

Their names provide a starting point for exploring intensity. Ricchiuti encourages people to taste different varieties and choose according to their preferences and how they plan to use the oil.

“A more intense oil isn’t necessarily better than a delicate one,” he says. “For us, quality comes down to freshness, balance, and producing an oil that lets the characteristics of the olives shine through.”

Think about the role you want the oil to play in a dish. A milder oil might suit a recipe where you want other ingredients to lead. A more peppery oil can contribute a distinctive flavor to a dressing or finishing drizzle.

A simple comparison can help. Taste small amounts of two oils alongside the same bread, paying attention to the aroma, bitterness and sensation at the back of your throat. You are learning which qualities you enjoy and where you might want to use them.

Put polyphenols in context

Polyphenols are naturally occurring compounds that contribute to olive oil’s antioxidant activity and sensory qualities, including bitterness and pepperiness. Their concentration can vary with olive variety, harvest timing, processing and storage.

That helps explain why flavor intensity and a polyphenol figure do not always line up neatly.

“Bitterness and pepperiness can be indicators of polyphenols, but they aren’t a perfect measure of how much an oil contains,” Ricchiuti says.

He encourages shoppers to consider freshness and flavor alongside any testing information. A pronounced peppery finish may appeal to one cook, while another prefers a gentler oil. Finding a well-made oil you enjoy using regularly is a practical way to approach the choice.

Use good olive oil in everyday cooking

Extra virgin olive oil works for sautéing and roasting as well as dressings and finishing. UC Davis’s guidance on olive oil and cooking supports its use under heat, with cooking properties influenced by the oil’s grade, quality and freshness.

“We want people to enjoy great olive oil in their kitchens every day, not feel like they have to save it for special occasions,” Ricchiuti says.

Let the recipe guide you. To highlight an oil’s distinctive flavor, use it in a dressing or add a drizzle at the end of cooking. For everyday vegetables and other meals, it can also be part of the cooking process.

Keeping those uses in mind makes choosing between varieties more intuitive. You might prefer one oil for a finishing drizzle and another for the dishes you cook most often.

Choose a useful size and store it well

Once opened, olive oil is exposed to air, which gradually affects its freshness. Keep the bottle tightly closed in a cool, dark cupboard away from the stove. Heat and light can also diminish its quality.

Bottle size matters because it affects how long the oil will sit open in your kitchen. ENZO offers its organic extra virgin olive oils in 250-milliliter and 500-milliliter bottles, along with 3-liter tins, through ENZO’S TABLE.

A smaller bottle can make sense when you are exploring a variety or use olive oil occasionally. A larger format may suit a household that cooks with it every day. Choose an amount you will use regularly and keep the remaining oil protected.

Ricchiuti describes fresh oil as having pleasant, fresh aromas. Oil that smells of old nuts or crayons, or tastes stale, is different from the natural bitterness and pepperiness you may notice in fresh extra virgin olive oil.

His advice brings the decision back to details any shopper can check: “You don’t need to be an expert; just look for freshness, transparency, and quality you can trace back to its source.”

ENZO provided complimentary samples of its Bold, Medium and Delicate olive oils for editorial consideration, along with product information and a written Q&A with co-founder and COO Vincent Ricchiuti. The brand did not pay for coverage and has no right to approve this article. First-person observations reflect the author’s use of those samples. Ricchiuti’s comments represent his perspective as a company co-founder; general information about olive oil is supported by the independent sources linked throughout.

This story was originally published by Men’s Fitness on Nov 5, 2026, where it first appeared in the Nutrition section. Add Men’s Fitness as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top