Key points
-
Food & Wine taste-tested 17 store-bought extra-virgin olive oils, evaluating each for aroma, flavor, and finish to identify the best supermarket options.
-
Lucini Italia earned the top score, followed by Kosterina, while Trader Joe’s, Colavita, and Pompeian tied for third.
-
The highest-rated olive oils stood out for their balanced flavors, distinctive aromas, and clean, lingering finishes, while lower-scoring bottles lacked complexity or had less appealing textures.
Olive oil does a lot of work in the kitchen, from sautéing vegetables to dressing salads and finishing a dish with a drizzle. But with so many bottles on grocery store shelves, choosing one can take a little guesswork.
To find out which are worth bringing home, Food & Wine food stylist Julian Hensarling teamed up with olive oil sommelier Sara Jimenez to taste 17 store-bought extra-virgin olive oils in a recent Food Flight video. They evaluated each for aroma, flavor, and finish, selecting the freshest bottles they could find based on harvest and best-by dates.
Lucini Italia earned the highest score, followed by Kosterina. Third place was a three-way tie between Trader Joe’s, Colavita, and Pompeian, giving the tasters five favorites across the top three finishes.
Warming olive oil before tasting helps release its aromas and flavors.Credit: Food & Wine
How we tasted the olive oils
As an olive oil sommelier, Jimenez evaluates aroma as well as flavor, describing fruity, floral, and herbaceous notes much as a wine sommelier might. Hensarling looks for oils he — and Food & Wine readers — would happily use in the kitchen.
Before tasting, Jimenez showed Hensarling how to warm the oil in his hands to release its aromas, then draw in air while sipping to help assess its flavor and finish. “I look for olive oils that linger on the finish that are really enjoyable and also very balanced,” she says.
Related: 9 Pro Tips on How to Buy and Use Good Olive Oil
Throughout the tasting, the pair noted aromas and flavors ranging from green grass and artichoke to banana and almond. A pleasant peppery finish helped distinguish several favorites, while flat flavors and waxy textures pushed other bottles down the rankings.
Hensarling wanted an oil with enough character to leave an impression. “To get a high score,” he said, he needed the sample to “really sit with me and say, ‘This is what I am. You need to remember me.’”
The top-scoring store-bought olive oils
1. Lucini Italia
Lucini Italia, made by California Olive Ranch, stood out for its combination of robust flavor, balance, and a clean, lingering finish. Both tasters awarded it a 9, the highest score of the tasting.
On the nose, Jimenez picked up fruit, fresh herbs, and green grass. The flavor delivered just as much character, with a peppery finish that stayed pleasant. “This is one of the more balanced ones we’ve had, but it’s robust at the same time,” Jimenez says.
Related: Graza Is My Go-To Everyday Olive Oil — and I’ve Tested It for More Than 3 Years
For Hensarling, the flavor continued to develop after each sip, making Lucini a bottle he’d seek out on his next grocery run. “Out of all of the olive oils,” he says, it “really gave me everything I was looking for in an olive oil.”
2. Kosterina
Kosterina’s Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil earned a 9 from Jimenez and an 8 from Hensarling, putting it in second place with an average of 8.5.
The Greek oil was the only single-varietal selection in the tasting. Both tasters found plenty to enjoy in its fruity flavor, with notes of banana, almond, and citrus leaf alongside a buttery quality.
Hensarling imagined using it with tomatoes and basil, while Jimenez recommended it for marinating, grilling, salads, and dishes with lemon. “It really, it expressed itself,” Hensarling says.
3. Trader Joe’s, Colavita, and Pompeian
Three oils tied for third place, each earning an 8 from both tasters. Their different strengths offer several directions for your next bottle.
Trader Joe’s Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil impressed with earthy aromas that reminded Jimenez of artichoke and green almond. Its peppery finish lingered without leaving an unpleasant aftertaste. “It finishes clean but you can still taste it,” Jimenez says.
Related: Ina Garten Says This Is the Best Olive Oil You Can Buy, and I Swear By It Too
Colavita delivered a fruitier profile, with banana and almond notes and a finish that held the tasters’ attention. Hensarling counted it among the oils he’d want in his kitchen, and Jimenez suggested a use beyond cooking: drizzling it over ice cream with a little salt.
Pompeian Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil offered grassy aromas, a hint of banana peel, and an almond note toward the end. It wasn’t as complex as Lucini, but both tasters found it easy to enjoy. “I would absolutely use this in my home,” Jimenez says.
Which store-bought olive oils made Food & Wine’s top 3?
Rank
Brand
Score
1
Lucini Italia
9
2
Kosterina
8.5
Tied for 3
Trader Joe’s
8
Tied for 3
Colavita
8
Tied for 3
Pompeian
8
What separated the favorites from the rest
The highest-scoring oils had distinct flavors and pleasant finishes, giving the tasters reasons to use them beyond the sauté pan. Other bottles struck them as mild but useful for everyday cooking. One bottle’s waxy flavor earned particularly low marks. “It tastes like a spicy box of crayons,” Jimenez says, giving it a 1 out of 10.
The tasting also gave both tasters reasons to reconsider bottles they’d previously passed over. As Hensarling says of Lucini, “I see this at grocery stores all the time and walk right past it. This is definitely gonna be one of the ones that I go for.”
Read the original article on Food & Wine
